Walter (view this story)

2 comments - Login to comment

Rep: 444
Eric Seals Feb. 24, 2013, 4:24 p.m. permalink

Hi Carlos,

I loved that you chose to have this in black and white. It had a nice look and feel to it and I like the way you see things.

I'm curious why you chose to mix video and stils and not just pick one and stick with it. This seemed like a very video kind of story to me. Showing all the hustle in the subway with his playing, the details of him strumming, tight on his face as he sings (I can tell from your stills he really gets into it)

I did like how short it was and I got his backstory about why he plays, how much he works and why he loves it.  At times however with the translation it was hard to read the words as they blended in with some of the background like at the 1:35 mark. I would suggest leaving it as is but put a light or dark gray bar behind the words so they stick out more and are easier to read.

The scene of the still at the 1:01 mark I absolutely love and imagine shooting that scene with video as he's miked up and plays as those people stream on by.

1) Be careful of going in and coming out of dip to blacks.  There were two spots in your piece where coming out into the next still it was abrupt because there was no dip to black like there was going in.

2) You audio was good, especially when Walter was playing

How long did you spend with Walter? 
For a profile piece like this I would of love to have seen this go full circle. Him on the subway riding it (showing the loner that he is) to his spot, arriving and setting up, the playing (wide, tight, medium shots, etc) crowd reaction, the busy of the subway, details of money being put into the guitar case, the trip back home.  

Then music. I wanted to hear more of it, he sounds really good.  Would of love to of had the music come up and down with the volume with built in transitions with nat sound breaks.

Hope that helps and sorry it took so long to get to the review.


Rep: 444
Eric Seals Feb. 24, 2013, 4:29 p.m. permalink

I forgot to add Carlos that having good and power stills with awesome audio can be great as long as the pacing and flow goes well.

I've seen many pieces done like that were the producer had certain still hang on the screen longer for impact with slow movement.

I'm not totally again stills only as long as it is editing good, tight and has great impact.


Login to comment


You must be logged in to like this story